Looking for storage units in Bay Shore, New York? Browse and compare 9 self-storage facilities side by side. 5x5 units start at $45/month. 3 of them publish a monthly rate and unit sizes, so you can compare those without ringing round.

Bay Shore storage options range from small 5x5 lockers to large 10x30 drive-up units, on flexible month-to-month terms. 2 facilities offer climate-controlled storage to protect furniture, electronics, and documents from heat and humidity. 2 offer drive-up access for loading straight from your vehicle. 1 provide 24-hour access. 4 have vehicle, RV, or boat storage. Compare amenities and prices below to find the right unit in Bay Shore.

Bay Shore storage prices by unit size

Averages from real units listed across Bay Shore, NY facilities, in US dollars. 22% of them mention climate-controlled units on their own website.

Size	Typical use	Median / mo	Average	Range	Units
5×10	Studio / small bedroom	$84	$85	$60 – $110	5
10×10	1-bedroom apartment	$183	$159	$135 – $183	2thin
10×15	Large 1-bed / small 2-bed	$256	$223	$190 – $256	2thin
10×20	2–3 bedroom home	$271	$270	$269 – $271	2thin
10×25	3-bedroom home	$345	$336	$326 – $345	2thin

Not sure which size you need? See the unit size guide or compare with the New York pricing overview.

Things you'll need

Disc lock

Required by most facilities

$12 Shop →

Storage bins

Better than cardboard for long-term

$35 Shop →

Shoulder Dolly

#1 best seller in moving straps

$30 Shop →

Affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure

Self Storage in Bay Shore — Common Questions

How much does self storage cost in Bay Shore, NY?

The cheapest 5x5 unit published in Bay Shore is $45/month. Prices rise with unit size, and operators charge more for a climate-controlled unit than a standard one. 3 of the 9 facilities we list in Bay Shore publish a rate you can compare, and the rest we ring for you.

How many self storage facilities are in Bay Shore?

There are 9 self storage facilities in Bay Shore, New York listed on StorageAtlas, including national chains and local operators. 3 of them publish a monthly rate; every listing carries the address, amenities and contact details we hold.

What size storage unit do I need in Bay Shore?

A 5×5 unit (25 sq ft) holds a few boxes or seasonal items. A 10×10 (100 sq ft) fits a 1-bedroom apartment. A 10×20 (200 sq ft) suits a full 2–3 bedroom home. Most people over-estimate — stacking boxes and taking furniture apart usually lets a smaller unit do the job. Go a size up only if you have large items that cannot be dismantled, like an appliance or a sofa bed.

Are there climate-controlled storage units in Bay Shore?

Yes — 2 of the 9 storage facilities in Bay Shore offer climate-controlled units. Climate control keeps temperatures stable year-round and is recommended for wood furniture, electronics, documents, artwork, and anything sensitive to heat or humidity.